Vous n'êtes pas identifié(e).
- Discussions : Actives | Sans réponse
Annonce
Eredan iTCG forums move. You can find them at this adress: http://forums.eredan.com/index.php.
Eredan GT forums stay here, the same for the old Eredan iTCG forums who pass in read only.
Les forums d'Eredan iTCG ont déménagés. Retrouvez-les à cette adresse : http://forums.eredan.com/index.php.
Les forums d'Eredan GT restent ici, ainsi que les anciens forums d'Eredan iTCG qui y seront toujours en lecture seule.
Pages : 1
#1 10-03-2012 07:37:48
- Jonas Albrecht
- Voyageur
- Inscription : 29-02-2012
- Messages : 28
A minor modification for Melissandre.
She's already a pretty decent Sap Heart, but for the most part, she exists primarily in Quick Draw decks, and a few MR decks that pass on Silikat. To make her more versitle, and to better represent her charecter, I recommend adding Beast as a race. It could be a stage 4 evolution if need be.
I play Sap Hearts. What? Someone has to.
"These are no longer abstractions. These are worlds, maybe there's life there that will change how we think about Earth."
Hors ligne
#2 10-03-2012 07:41:28
- Santuros
- Nehantiste
- Lieu : Colombia!!!
- Inscription : 17-10-2010
- Messages : 998
Re : A minor modification for Melissandre.
She's already a pretty decent Sap Heart, but for the most part, she exists primarily in Quick Draw decks, and a few MR decks that pass on Silikat. To make her more versitle, and to better represent her charecter, I recommend adding Beast as a race. It could be a stage 4 evolution if need be.
disagree!!! with the collar the QD deck would be op...
I wish I could show you when you are lonely or in darkness the astonishing light of your own being. (Hafez)
Hors ligne
#3 10-03-2012 07:44:17
- Jonas Albrecht
- Voyageur
- Inscription : 29-02-2012
- Messages : 28
Re : A minor modification for Melissandre.
Jonas Albrecht a écrit :She's already a pretty decent Sap Heart, but for the most part, she exists primarily in Quick Draw decks, and a few MR decks that pass on Silikat. To make her more versitle, and to better represent her charecter, I recommend adding Beast as a race. It could be a stage 4 evolution if need be.
disagree!!! with the collar the QD deck would be op...
That could be fixed by getting rid of her inherent second attack.
I play Sap Hearts. What? Someone has to.
"These are no longer abstractions. These are worlds, maybe there's life there that will change how we think about Earth."
Hors ligne
#4 10-03-2012 08:03:44
- genesyx
- Habitant de Guem
- Inscription : 21-01-2011
- Messages : 195
Re : A minor modification for Melissandre.
Santuros a écrit :Jonas Albrecht a écrit :She's already a pretty decent Sap Heart, but for the most part, she exists primarily in Quick Draw decks, and a few MR decks that pass on Silikat. To make her more versitle, and to better represent her charecter, I recommend adding Beast as a race. It could be a stage 4 evolution if need be.
disagree!!! with the collar the QD deck would be op...
That could be fixed by getting rid of her inherent second attack.
Why bother making her an elfine for quick draw then if she's without her 2nd attack? Adding a beast for her wouldn't make her "more versatile" (she'll still exist mainly in QD and MR and none of the other sap heart decks).
Also even if she were to sacrifice her 2nd attack for the beast race, what about the other elfines? They still can reap the add. attack from collar, AND have their bonus attack.
Attack+2nd attack+collar+quick draw??? that's too OP IMO.
Hors ligne
#5 10-03-2012 08:09:04
- Jonas Albrecht
- Voyageur
- Inscription : 29-02-2012
- Messages : 28
Re : A minor modification for Melissandre.
Jonas Albrecht a écrit :Santuros a écrit :disagree!!! with the collar the QD deck would be op...
That could be fixed by getting rid of her inherent second attack.
Why bother making her an elfine for quick draw then if she's without her 2nd attack? Adding a beast for her wouldn't make her "more versatile" (she'll still exist mainly in QD and MR and none of the other sap heart decks).
Also even if she were to sacrifice her 2nd attack for the beast race, what about the other elfines? They still can reap the add. attack from collar, AND have their bonus attack.
Attack+2nd attack+collar+quick draw??? that's too OP IMO.
True, she'd still end up in QD and MR decks, but players would also have a solid Sap Hearts Beast to experiment with.
As to the last part, can't they do that already by having Mel/Chestnut/Pilferess?
I play Sap Hearts. What? Someone has to.
"These are no longer abstractions. These are worlds, maybe there's life there that will change how we think about Earth."
Hors ligne
#6 10-03-2012 18:11:49
- Nurvus
- Gardien
- Inscription : 01-12-2010
- Messages : 2 526
Re : A minor modification for Melissandre.
You start by saying that Melissandre shouldfit in more decks, and would like her to have Beast race to that end.
But then you suggest she loses her inherent second Attack to compensate for the effectiveness she'd have with Butterfly Collar.
That, would break most decks she currently fits in.
This makes you come out as short-sighted at best, hypocritical at worst.
---
I think this is a terrible suggestion because:
- Would make The Sachem useless.
- Would make most Beasts useless.
It'd empower Living Nature/etc decks, because you'd have Keizan + Rockspeaker + Melissandre = 5 races.
Dernière modification par Nurvus (10-03-2012 18:12:15)
Hors ligne
#7 10-03-2012 18:26:49
- Jonas Albrecht
- Voyageur
- Inscription : 29-02-2012
- Messages : 28
Re : A minor modification for Melissandre.
This makes you come out as short-sighted at best, hypocritical at worst.
While I do not mind being disagreed with, I don't think the conversation requires this.
I play Sap Hearts. What? Someone has to.
"These are no longer abstractions. These are worlds, maybe there's life there that will change how we think about Earth."
Hors ligne
Pages : 1