Annonce

Eredan iTCG forums move. You can find them at this adress: http://forums.eredan.com/index.php.

Eredan GT forums stay here, the same for the old Eredan iTCG forums who pass in read only.

Les forums d'Eredan iTCG ont déménagés. Retrouvez-les à cette adresse : http://forums.eredan.com/index.php.

Les forums d'Eredan GT restent ici, ainsi que les anciens forums d'Eredan iTCG qui y seront toujours en lecture seule.

#1 01-02-2012 11:52:47

Roarky
Habitant de Guem
Inscription : 12-01-2011
Messages : 200

Shulong traits

I just faced fog hydra and my shuolong spirit turned to 0 (zero) because of hydra effect...

Is this supposed to be like this? or does shulong effect negates the spirit = 0 effect from hydra?

Thx for the explanation in advance


Hors ligne

#2 01-02-2012 12:51:10

Zurga
Modérateur Eredan
Inscription : 20-04-2010
Messages : 11 566

Re : Shulong traits

The game behave differently if the card says +1 or -1 on traits or if the card says =1 or =0

In the first case, this is a bonus/malus
In the second case, this is the definition of a new base value.

All the card that not allow to change the traits are based on bonus/malus.
When you fix the new value, you can do it all time.

For example, [card]Lady Yilith[/card] that play [card]Spiritual duel[/card] can bypass the limitation of bonus/malus on her traits.

The Fog hydra gives =0 on the spirit, not a modification of the Spirit but the definition of a new base value.
The game allow it.

Dernière modification par Zurga (01-02-2012 12:51:42)


Collectionneur de cartes


Hors ligne

#3 01-02-2012 13:16:40

soulst3al3r
Solarian
Inscription : 14-09-2011
Messages : 722

Re : Shulong traits

Zurga a écrit :

The game behave differently if the card says +1 or -1 on traits or if the card says =1 or =0

In the first case, this is a bonus/malus
In the second case, this is the definition of a new base value.

All the card that not allow to change the traits are based on bonus/malus.
When you fix the new value, you can do it all time.

For example, [card]Lady Yilith[/card] that play [card]Spiritual duel[/card] can bypass the limitation of bonus/malus on her traits.

The Fog hydra gives =0 on the spirit, not a modification of the Spirit but the definition of a new base value.
The game allow it.

In light of this development, do cards like reborn and distracted then effectively lower their attks? additionally, does the scroll of weakness + lucky charm combo work agaisnt the shulongs?


Hors ligne

#4 01-02-2012 13:35:35

Zurga
Modérateur Eredan
Inscription : 20-04-2010
Messages : 11 566

Re : Shulong traits

If the card says =X, yes it works.

So :
- [card]Reborn[/card], yes
- [card]Distracted[/card], yes
- [card]scroll of weakness[/card], No 
- [card]lucky charm[/card], yes

[card]Sroll of Failtry[/card] + [card]Self-Confidence[/card] works (Bomzar combo of the death)


Collectionneur de cartes


Hors ligne

#5 01-02-2012 13:44:06

soulst3al3r
Solarian
Inscription : 14-09-2011
Messages : 722

Re : Shulong traits

Zurga a écrit :

If the card says =X, yes it works.

So :
- [card]Reborn[/card], yes
- [card]Distracted[/card], yes
- [card]scroll of weakness[/card], No 
- [card]lucky charm[/card], yes

[card]Sroll of Failtry[/card] + [card]Self-Confidence[/card] works (Bomzar combo of the death)

lol i meant scroll of frailty + lucky charm


Hors ligne

#6 01-02-2012 14:40:30

PhoenixBlue
Habitant de Guem
Inscription : 29-01-2012
Messages : 166

Re : Shulong traits

enemy distracted not work @ my vulnurable shulong.. my shulong still have 4 def when they use distracted.. vulnurable shulong vs vulnurable shulong


IGN : Phoenix_Blue


Hors ligne

#7 01-02-2012 15:59:48

Roarky
Habitant de Guem
Inscription : 12-01-2011
Messages : 200

Re : Shulong traits

Really? But [card]Magic Attack[/card] works on my Shulong...

And does [card]Magic Shield[/card] aslo considered bonus or not? coz it cuts the attacks half

Dernière modification par Roarky (01-02-2012 16:00:47)


Hors ligne

#8 01-02-2012 17:31:25

Nurvus
Gardien
Inscription : 01-12-2010
Messages : 2 526

Re : Shulong traits

Zurga a écrit :

If the card says =X, yes it works.

So :
- [card]Reborn[/card], yes
- [card]Distracted[/card], yes
- [card]scroll of weakness[/card], No 
- [card]lucky charm[/card], yes

[card]Sroll of Failtry[/card] + [card]Self-Confidence[/card] works (Bomzar combo of the death)

[card]Obesity[/card], no.
[card]Distracted[/card], no
[card]Magic Shield[/card], yes.

So you're wrong.
Either they can be modified or they can't.
Changing the value of a card is for all purposes, modifying it.
In Shulong's case, it is a bug and shouldn't happen.

Otherwise just change the card's text because right now it says it can't be changed.

Dernière modification par Nurvus (01-02-2012 17:33:45)


Hors ligne

#9 01-02-2012 17:39:01

PhoenixBlue
Habitant de Guem
Inscription : 29-01-2012
Messages : 166

Re : Shulong traits

magic attack not work on my shulong


IGN : Phoenix_Blue


Hors ligne

#10 01-02-2012 17:52:34

Zurga
Modérateur Eredan
Inscription : 20-04-2010
Messages : 11 566

Re : Shulong traits

So Shulong is buggued a lot.
It should work like [card]Lady Yilith[/card] or like [card]Kimiko[/card], not not the two at the same time.

My bad if it is not the case.
I have not played with Shulong actually.

Dernière modification par Zurga (01-02-2012 17:52:49)


Collectionneur de cartes


Hors ligne

#11 01-02-2012 17:59:34

Nurvus
Gardien
Inscription : 01-12-2010
Messages : 2 526

Re : Shulong traits

Zurga a écrit :

So Shulong is buggued a lot.
It should work like [card]Lady Yilith[/card] or like [card]Kimiko[/card], not not the two at the same time.

My bad if it is not the case.
I have not played with Shulong actually.

I've played and seen a lengthy video of someone using it, spamming Obesities.
I decided to try Magic Shield and other stat modifying cards to "test it".

I mean, shouldn't testers be doing that? :> I found some bugs so quickly... and so easily.


Hors ligne

#12 01-02-2012 18:25:51

Calandra
Gardien
Lieu : Dickes B, oben an der Spree
Inscription : 09-04-2011
Messages : 1 751

Re : Shulong traits

unfortunenatly they are not using pre-release testing phase for new cards as it was once suggested... they simply toss new cards out like crazy and then try to solve the bugs... horrible logic imo


Wash the spears... while the sun climbs high.
Wash the spears... while the sun climbs low.
Wash the spears... who fears to die?
Wash the spears... no one I know!


Hors ligne

#13 01-02-2012 18:29:50

Zurga
Modérateur Eredan
Inscription : 20-04-2010
Messages : 11 566

Re : Shulong traits

It is not the case, but testers have limited time and not always all the ideas of the players.
Even some time the ideas are very basic and they should have them....


Collectionneur de cartes


Hors ligne

#14 01-02-2012 18:57:34

Calandra
Gardien
Lieu : Dickes B, oben an der Spree
Inscription : 09-04-2011
Messages : 1 751

Re : Shulong traits

if the current system is not sufficient... change it until it works... send 100 messages to players giving them cards which will be released soon to test and as a compensation u ll give them 1k crystals or 100 feez... i swear they ll do it... even for less


Wash the spears... while the sun climbs high.
Wash the spears... while the sun climbs low.
Wash the spears... who fears to die?
Wash the spears... no one I know!


Hors ligne

#15 01-02-2012 21:28:15

Zurga
Modérateur Eredan
Inscription : 20-04-2010
Messages : 11 566

Re : Shulong traits

You preach to the choir, I'm not part of the staff. I'm only a player like anyone else.


Collectionneur de cartes


Hors ligne

#16 01-02-2012 21:50:09

Nurvus
Gardien
Inscription : 01-12-2010
Messages : 2 526

Re : Shulong traits

Zurga a écrit :

You preach to the choir, I'm not part of the staff. I'm only a player like anyone else.

I'm not complaining about you, Zurga - you're awesome.
I just pointed out what I think is wrong, and discussing the arguments you presented.

The way so many cards that should work the same don't work the same, I have to say it simply feels like the programmers made 1 distinct effect for each card, instead of programming a single version of each effect (with variables) and assigning them to various cards that use them, thus enforcing that all similar effects work the same.

Dernière modification par Nurvus (01-02-2012 21:52:31)


Hors ligne

#17 01-02-2012 21:52:18

Zurga
Modérateur Eredan
Inscription : 20-04-2010
Messages : 11 566

Re : Shulong traits

No problem Nurvus, I was wrong, you're right wink


Collectionneur de cartes


Hors ligne

#18 02-02-2012 10:48:40

Roarky
Habitant de Guem
Inscription : 12-01-2011
Messages : 200

Re : Shulong traits

Hopefully shulong traits cant be changed with any cards...


Hors ligne

#19 02-02-2012 12:46:01

PhoenixBlue
Habitant de Guem
Inscription : 29-01-2012
Messages : 166

Re : Shulong traits

shulong traits cant be enchance or reduced.. but now they make shulong a toy ? magic attack can make my shulong 0 defence.. then winter truce make my shulong attack -2... how can ? it say shulong trait cant enchanced or reduced... feel disappoint


IGN : Phoenix_Blue


Hors ligne

#20 02-02-2012 12:51:00

Zurga
Modérateur Eredan
Inscription : 20-04-2010
Messages : 11 566

Re : Shulong traits

http://forum.eredan.com/viewtopic.php?p … 98#p486798

http://forum.eredan.com/viewtopic.php?p … 58#p488158

Zurga is the best, Zurga knows all, Zurga knows always the truth, trust no one else Zurga  wink

Actually, the correction of the card suffers some flaws.
But What I have said stands : "=X" works again Shulong.

Dernière modification par Zurga (02-02-2012 12:51:30)


Collectionneur de cartes


Hors ligne

#21 02-02-2012 12:54:57

Aigle1705
Gardien
Lieu : Germany - Tilleda (Kyffhäuser)
Inscription : 12-12-2010
Messages : 1 500

Re : Shulong traits


silent leges inter arma
cicero


Hors ligne

#22 02-02-2012 12:55:54

Zurga
Modérateur Eredan
Inscription : 20-04-2010
Messages : 11 566

Re : Shulong traits

Like I said, "-X" is a bug.
"=X" should work after the complete correction.


Collectionneur de cartes


Hors ligne

#23 02-02-2012 12:58:05

PhoenixBlue
Habitant de Guem
Inscription : 29-01-2012
Messages : 166

Re : Shulong traits

so '+ x' bug too ?
lol then winter truce is bugs @ shulong


IGN : Phoenix_Blue


Hors ligne

#24 02-02-2012 19:11:12

Nurvus
Gardien
Inscription : 01-12-2010
Messages : 2 526

Re : Shulong traits

Zurga a écrit :

Like I said, "-X" is a bug.
"=X" should work after the complete correction.

I'm disappointed.
To be honest that's just an underhanded way for Feerik to nerf the dragon after people spent alot of time trying to get it.
It's not even that strong.

I used [card]Punch Line[/card] because the dragon ignored the "attack = min attack" penalty.
Now it seems it got "hotfixed" and applies the penalty.

I tried Scroll of Frailty, Magic Shield, etc.
Now it will make the dragon fail when he uses Obesity, Scroll of Frailty...
Other characters will be able to use Magic Attack against the Dragon.

In short, the dragon is going to be stomped.


Hors ligne

#25 02-02-2012 19:25:26

PhoenixBlue
Habitant de Guem
Inscription : 29-01-2012
Messages : 166

Re : Shulong traits

Nurvus a écrit :
Zurga a écrit :

Like I said, "-X" is a bug.
"=X" should work after the complete correction.

I'm disappointed.
To be honest that's just an underhanded way for Feerik to nerf the dragon after people spent alot of time trying to get it.
It's not even that strong.

I used [card]Punch Line[/card] because the dragon ignored the "attack = min attack" penalty.
Now it seems it got "hotfixed" and applies the penalty.

I tried Scroll of Frailty, Magic Shield, etc.
Now it will make the dragon fail when he uses Obesity, Scroll of Frailty...
Other characters will be able to use Magic Attack against the Dragon.

In short, the dragon is going to be stomped.

witchblade deck use magic attack and easily kill my dragon
but they wear so many armor + sword + some eggy (exodium) or something cloth and my dragon not wear anything.

This not realy fair for Mythical solo card Shulong. When opposite have high spirit+armor, how we beat 1v3 if now they can treat Shulong Status.. Like magic ball (uncommon) and zarazam's eye.

Don't know now Shulong can wear weapon / sword / any armor and increase Shulong status or not..

So just wana say... I don't know where's the point Shulong trait cant be enchanced or reduced.... Winter Truce and Wanted! also work @ shulong.


IGN : Phoenix_Blue


Hors ligne

Pied de page des forums