Vous n'êtes pas identifié(e).
- Discussions : Actives | Sans réponse
Annonce
Eredan iTCG forums move. You can find them at this adress: http://forums.eredan.com/index.php.
Eredan GT forums stay here, the same for the old Eredan iTCG forums who pass in read only.
Les forums d'Eredan iTCG ont déménagés. Retrouvez-les à cette adresse : http://forums.eredan.com/index.php.
Les forums d'Eredan GT restent ici, ainsi que les anciens forums d'Eredan iTCG qui y seront toujours en lecture seule.
Pages : 1
#1 28-09-2011 15:10:40
- Nessaj
- Guémélite
- Inscription : 19-09-2011
- Messages : 443
Better than "Magic Attack"?
With the new cards this week, is magic attack dead now? That one that reduces your enemy's defense to zero.
Distracted Rare. Action. At the start of the fight, the opposing character has Defense = 0 until the end of the fight. Chain. Duration: 3 Fights.
Now this is for 3 fights and is a chain, not 1 fight only like magic attack that is no chain.
This is good to pwn those high defense decks like kotobas and dks 
Evil is just a point of view >)
Hors ligne
#2 28-09-2011 15:41:02
- Aigle1705
- Gardien
- Lieu : Germany - Tilleda (Kyffhäuser)
- Inscription : 12-12-2010
- Messages : 1 500
Re : Better than "Magic Attack"?
its only in fight 2 and 3.
not first fight, cause fight starts befor cards are activated.
in fight 2 n 3 def=0 comes befor all new cards, so he can push def again.
in that case i would say magic attack stays the better choice, more controll
silent leges inter arma
cicero
Hors ligne
#3 28-09-2011 15:57:26
- Nessaj
- Guémélite
- Inscription : 19-09-2011
- Messages : 443
Re : Better than "Magic Attack"?
umm.. I understood now, i thought it got the effect right away.
So yes, this card may be good for the decks with some ramp up time to damage, so they can release max damage when pumped.
Magic attack is something more controlled, you choose who you want to use to fight the opponent without defense, now with "Distracted" you dont know which of your characters will fight him next time.
Evil is just a point of view >)
Hors ligne
#4 28-09-2011 16:11:46
- Luxo2011
- Eredanien
- Inscription : 29-07-2010
- Messages : 5 652
Re : Better than "Magic Attack"?
in fight 2 n 3 def=0 comes befor all new cards, so he can push def again.
The card says Def = 0 until end of combat...
GT: Kotoba Gangnam Style
Hors ligne
#5 28-09-2011 16:33:24
- Roarky
- Habitant de Guem
- Inscription : 12-01-2011
- Messages : 200
Re : Better than "Magic Attack"?
Distracted Rare. Action. At the start of the fight, the opposing character has Defense = 0 until the end of the fight. Chain. Duration: 3 Fights.
It is like Vengeful Lianas, u get the effect on the next fight not at the 1st one...
Its good if u can survive the 1st fight...
Hors ligne
#6 28-09-2011 17:12:19
- Aigle1705
- Gardien
- Lieu : Germany - Tilleda (Kyffhäuser)
- Inscription : 12-12-2010
- Messages : 1 500
Re : Better than "Magic Attack"?
Aigle1705 a écrit :in fight 2 n 3 def=0 comes befor all new cards, so he can push def again.
The card says Def = 0 until end of combat...
it says the effect ends at end of combat not that it cant be changed again.
silent leges inter arma
cicero
Hors ligne
#7 02-10-2011 22:29:47
- Nurvus
- Gardien
- Inscription : 01-12-2010
- Messages : 2 526
Re : Better than "Magic Attack"?
Luxo2011 a écrit :Aigle1705 a écrit :in fight 2 n 3 def=0 comes befor all new cards, so he can push def again.
The card says Def = 0 until end of combat...
it says the effect ends at end of combat not that it cant be changed again.
True, yet does [card]Magic Attack[/card] or [card]Scroll of Immobility[/card] say "until the end of combat"?
Just establish a default and stick to it.
If you want the default behavior of effects to be "until the end of combat", then do not state it in any card. Only state anything if it lasts until the end of Turn, Game or if it's Permanent.
If you want the default behavior of effects to be Permanent, then do not state it in any card. Only state anything if it lasts until the end of Combat, Turn or Game.
Define a universal wording like you did for Items, please.
Dernière modification par Nurvus (02-10-2011 22:35:07)
Hors ligne
#8 02-10-2011 23:52:15
- goscar
- Guémélite
- Inscription : 03-12-2010
- Messages : 500
Re : Better than "Magic Attack"?
The thing with Magic attack and Scroll of Immobility is that they don't say that the Def=0 is permanent nor are the cards themselves permanent. Distraction is somewhat permanent and last for 2 turns. After combat is over the defense will be restored until it re-enters combat and get Def=0.
Dragon Knights ftw 
Hors ligne
#9 03-10-2011 00:07:20
- Nurvus
- Gardien
- Inscription : 01-12-2010
- Messages : 2 526
Re : Better than "Magic Attack"?
I see.
So it only states the Def = 0 lasts until the end of the fight because the card itself has a different duration.
Makes sense.
But does that mean every card in the game that doesn't say anything lasts until the end of the fight?
[card]Crystallization[/card] vs [card]Cutlass[/card]
- All permanents now state that they are Permanent.
Crystallization is permanent (and states so) and states the opposing character gets -1 Attack whenever he attacks you.
This Attack penalty remains as long as the card is in play.
Cutlass is permanent (but doesn't state so) and states the opposing character gets -1 Defense at the start of each fight.
This Defense penalty remains only until the end of the fight (but doesn't say so).
Following the example of [card]Distracted[/card], Cutlass should state "until the end of the fight" because the duration of the effect is different from the duration of the card itself.
I hope I'm clear this time.
Yet I acknowledge a degree of universal wording has already been implemented into the game.
Just keep it up
Dernière modification par Nurvus (03-10-2011 00:11:54)
Hors ligne
Pages : 1